Site Information

 Loading... Please wait...

Isaac v Minister of Consumer Affairs - [1990] 2 NZLR 606


High Court Wellington
23, 24, 26 April; 15 May 1990
Tipping J
Administrative law — Judicial review — Fairness — Unreasonableness — Minister of Consumer Affairs received reports concerning safety of bicycles sold by importer and invited him to recall them — When importer refused to do so, Minister ordered recall of 1200 bicycles with full refund to be made to purchasers — Whether Minister had acted with procedural unfairness in failing to provide importer with full copies of reports she had received — Whether Minister had acted unfairly in treating importer differently to other suppliers of bicycles — Whether Minister had acted unreasonably in failing to take relevant considerations into account — Whether relief should be granted — Fair Trading Act 1986, s 32.

Find Similar Products by Courts